Slash-and-Burn… The Art of Making Revisions

Times I have read the first chapter of my novel: 147

Times I have thought it was perfect: 0

Times I have known what to do to fix it: 4  18  0

Yesterday I went to writing group. While many people I meet seem to think being a writer is interesting and super-fun (though non-world-saving), they also don’t think there is much “work” involved. My BFF/running guru thought all that talk about going to writing group involved sitting around talking and drinking (which isn’t such a bad idea). What it really involves is homework and critique-making and critique-receiving and effort and perseverance to improve on both the front end and back end.

We meet about once every three to four weeks, and three of us submit roughly 20 pages each. I enjoy seeing each person’s (very different) novel developing and learning from some writing group friends who are amazing revision-makers. Fearlessly, they slash and burn huge chunks of their babies copy until they are left with the nugget of truth every agent will die to get his or her hands on someday. Me, not so much. Revision is a stumbling block for me, and something I am learning the hard way, over years, not days.

Now, I am going to tell you a secret. Don’t tell the agents out there about it yet:

The first chapter of my novel stinks.

That is the take-away from yesterday’s meeting. I have a very nice group of writer friends who have been helpful and supportive about the last three-quarters of the book. But they are so right about the opening of my novel. The unfortunate part of querying to find an agent is that you send out, in almost every case, the first chapter or so of your novel. When the first chapter is the “sick” part, you need to get back to work.

Like many writers, I am not an editor. Of course, it is easier to see what is wrong with other peoples’ work than it is to see the errors in your own writing. This is why writing critique groups are so important for the delicate job of making revisions.

A fantastic writer working alone may be able to see key issues and improve upon them. But for those of us mere mortals, writing groups full of fantastic minds and hawk-eyes can help tease out the reasons your manuscript isn’t gelling on some fundamental level.

One of the fears I have when I sense something isn’t right with my work is that in changing it from the ground up, I will only make it different, not necessarily better. Getting initial feedback and later, feedback on the revisions, has made me (I hope) a more thoughtful writer.

My goal for the week is to go in cold with a blank sheet of paper computer screen and start the novel from scratch. Something about this first novel has to get resolved before I can move on fully to the second one.

To all you Master Revisionists out there, send me good vibes and happy word choices!


9 thoughts on “Slash-and-Burn… The Art of Making Revisions

  1. Bernie Brown says:

    I’m sending good vibes your way, but I also have confidence in your wonderful skills. And I think “stinks” is way harsh AND not true. I suffer with you. 🙂

  2. annewoodman says:

    Thanks, Bernie. Can’t wait to give it another try and get some feedback from you guys. It may be harsh, but the truth hurts. ; )

  3. crubin says:

    I know exactly where you’re coming from. You know you’ve read your chapter repeatedly when you can cite the sentences from memory!

    Thanks for stopping by my blog a couple times and commenting. Appreciate it!

  4. During my first session at my first writer’s group, I was told that the book should start on the last paragraph of the first chapter. I revised the first chapter twice with the same result. Finally, Took their advise and rewrote the first chapter from scratch. It was hard but I am more satisfied with the result. Try a new beginning and see what happens.

    • annewoodman says:

      Dennis, I think you’re completely correct. There is a lot to fix, but I’m sure it will be stronger when I’m finished. Thank goodness for fellow writers’ advice!

  5. I submit to my group tomorrow (totally nervous, revising my revisions, losing sleep, and revising some more) and you are RIGHT ON with your thoughtful observations. =)

    • annewoodman says:

      Good luck as you submit. I find that I’ve gotten more and more open to hearing the criticism and the parts I need to fix. It’s made me a much better writer. I’d like to hear sometime what you’re writing!

  6. annewoodman says:

    Mine’s about four women in a wine club… a women’s friendship. Not high concept, and it has some “quiet” issues. ; )

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s